Every Bob who wishes to be Betty

I have previously suggested that the dreadful Athena Swan Charter should be put out of its misery. For anyone unaware of what the Athena Swan Charter is about it purports to be a ‘ a framework which is used across the globe to support and transform gender equality within higher education’. Belinda Brown has previously exposed the excesses of the Athena Swan in terms of its penetration of a major university, the dangers in promoting equality over excellence and how some subjects already have a surfeit of women to the disadvantage of men.

Initially aimed at ‘advancing the careers of women in science, technology, engineering, maths and medicine’, the rise of the transgender movement has led to mission creep towards the charter ‘now being used across the globe to address gender equality more broadly, and not just barriers to progression that affect women’.

So, not only concerned about the plight of women in these so called STEM subjects, Athena Swan has become another set of shoulders behind the woke battering ram that is demolishing most of what sensible people find reasonable. Thankfully this may be hoisting the Athena Swan Charter by its own petard.

Apparently, the gender (as opposed to biological sex) aspect of the charter has led feminists to complain that data on both are being conflated. Therefore, they begin to lose meaning and, while overrepresenting the overall success of the charter they underrepresent the specific success in relation to women.

The essential problem is that biological males, self-identifying as women, described as ‘transgender women’ will be included in the figures. This means that every Bob who wishes to be referred to as Betty inflates the success of Athena Swan and may be exploiting the charter to climb the greasy academic pole.

It must be assumed that transgender women working in STEM subjects are no stupider than the rest of their colleagues in the university sector and academics tend to suffer from a heady combination of intelligence, ambition and entitlement. What better way for an under-achieving male academic to achieve promotion than to self-identify as a woman?

With any luck the ongoing battle between the feminist and lesbian lobbies with the transgender lobby as exemplified by the recent shocking treatment of Kathleen Stock will tear the Athena Swan charter apart.

If that happens then women working in universities will feel less pressured into ascending to the heights of academia and to being made to feel like failures if they have prioritised having a family over spending long hours in the lab. Those who wish to ascend to the heights will be able to do so safe in the knowledge that they have attained those heights through achievement and not preferential treatment based on their biological sex (or gender).

Moreover, the army of academics—mainly female—who must dedicate their time to the inordinate data gathering, meetings and form-filling required to comply with the Athena Swan charter will be freed to pursue some academic work. This may, in fact, secure for some of them the promotion that has thus far eluded them.

The higher education sector will save thousands of pounds which could be ploughed back into better teaching. Everyone is a winner: universities; women; and students. If the Athena Swan is found upside down in a canal, so much the better.

Roger Watson is a Professor of Nursing

Subscribe to the quarterly print magazine

Subscribe to the quarterly digital magazine

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 Comments on Every Bob who wishes to be Betty

  1. Yes, the education systems have given up the hard work of educating the young (and old) and now pursue the destruction of the underpinnings of Western Civ.

    Main point is that, very soon, only small enclaves of white people -and among them, very tiny numbers of non-whites- in the UK and elsewhere in the Anglosphere, will be capable of maintaining communities that we once regarded as being OK to quite good.

    These enclaves will include parents who give up their time spent in various forms of entertainment/escapism -and instead devote their energies to educating and training their children to apprehend and deal with Actual Reality, in its various aspects.

    The rest will be Wasteland -the contours, quagmires, and violence of which are already very plain to see.

    • The Campaign for Real Education is a small light in the darkness (qv online).
      We need something like the Open University to preserve, protect and promote western civilization, especially its Classical basis and its English development. My Bibliography (also online) for The Royal Society of St George is a contribution to the latter. We need in Britain, which has less free speech than (say) the USA or Denmark, an accessible library which has not been permanently purged of so-called “racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, misogynist, nationalist, elitist, capitalist, militarist, classist, offensive, DWEM, xenophobic, colonialist, imperialist, reactionary, fascist, climate-denialist, far-right, religiously-bigoted,’Islamophobic’ and/or ‘Anti-semitic’ tropes or sentences”.